After the stimulus: Interest rates more volatile!
Interest rates more volatile? Rate cuts have become a regular affair but the consumer and banker is not enthused about borrowing or lending. Both need a bigger push from the government
In recent times, interest rates have turned more volatile than equity markets. Not surprising considering the fact that there is talk of a rate cut on a weekly basis. It is the expectation of these cuts which is keeping the Indian market swing in a wide range. If you look at some of the other global markets, the volatility in interest rates is not exciting for traders. Now, will we have a rate and if it comes through, will it get us out of the current slowdown which is all around us?
In fact, many have been complaining that life hasn’t changed in a big way after the recent rate cut which has pushed banks to cut down interest rate by 0.75%. The crib is that home loan rates are still in double digit and well above the comfort zone for many. As a result, borrowers are not exactly rushing to banks for buying property or cars.
If government is thinking of another cut in interest rate or stimulus package, it is due to the non responsive behaviour of the consumers. However, for the consumer, the problem is not merely on the rate front. In the case of property, developers are unwilling to press the price revision button having created land banks during real estate boom. As a result, you still find the property prices on the higher side as the developer is not ready to offer a discount of more than 15-25% in interest rate. In the case of cars, the story is entirely different.
So who need not worry about interest rates? Car manufacturers have been faced with the challenge of rising inventory and have begun to lower prices but the consumer is not ready to bring in a new car in a hurry. The reasons for lack of enthusiasm are plenty but top among them is the uncertain future. If the salaried is not sure if he will have the same pay cheque for the next one year, the uncertainty is of a different kind for the self-employed who account for a good chunk of car buying population at this time of the year. For these entrepreneurs, receivables are mounting and cash is turning out to be a rare commodity. With the economic recovery threatening to take more time to return to normalcy, the entrepreneurs are not in a hurry to invest on new wheels.
It is in this background one has to view the economic packages being unleashed by the government. In an election year, the government is keen on reviving the sentiment which has taken a huge beating. The uncertainty, liquidity crunch and the lack of enthusiasm among consumers to loosen their purse strings is not having the desired impact and hence, the Union government has been pushed to get more aggressive with its goodies. That’s why now you hear about income tax sops on home loans, higher investment limit for Section 80c and there is even talk of the government pushing builders to offer steeper discounts. Banks have already been told to get back to lending rather than focus on government securities. In the past few months, banks have resorted to increased scale of treasury operations. Not surprising considering that government securities have become the most profitable option for improving bottom line. The focus on treasury has been an easy option for banks in an era of falling interest rates. As you are aware, the yield from government securities goes up in inverse proportion to the prevailing interest rates and the sharp fall in the last few months has helped the yield to be in the range of over 15%. Unless there is pressure on them to get back to lending, banks may continue to rely on treasury profits for their good health. Only government has the wherewithal to push them.
